Evaluating an Argument |
Week1 |
|
(Preparation for class) |
|
(In-class activities) |
Jan
17
|
1 |
|
|
- Introduction to Course Policies and Goals
- Introduce in-class writing assignment for 1/22.
|
|
Week 2 |
Jan
22
|
2 |
- Prepare in-class writing assignment according to directions.
|
|
- Do in-class writing assignment.
|
Jan
24
|
3 |
- Read Chapter 1 (3-21) in Writing Arguments (WA).
-
- Read pages 289-96, 300-302 in WA.
- Do exercise on page 295-96 for one of the classes listed (a-i).
-
- Read pp.445-47 in WA.
|
|
- What is a good argument?
- Review exercise on p.295-96.
-
- Introduce Evaluation Essay Assignment.
-
- Evaluation is a Criteria Match.
- Do Task 1, p.446 in class.
- Do Task 2, p.447 in class.
|
|
- Week 3
|
Jan
29
|
4 |
- Do Task 3, pp.447-48 in WA.
- Read Chapter 2 (22-48) in WA.
- Read pp.305-6 in WA.
|
|
- Do Task 4, p.454 in class.
- Develop and defend criteria for good argumentation.
- How "Says and Does" helps you understand what you read.
- Do exercise on p.28 in class.
|
Jan
31
|
5 |
- Read "Marijuana for Medical Purposes" in Expository Writing 200 (EW 200), pp.115-16.
- Write "says" and "does" statements for
each paragraph. (Your goal: to understand the argument's major
claims and how it is put together.)
|
|
- Understanding the How and What of an Argument.
- Discussion of essay and "says" and "does"
statements.
|
|
Week 4 |
Feb
5
|
6 |
- Read EW200, pp.55-66.
- Complete Respond Question
Series for one of the two sample essays. (Follow hyperlink
to access questions.)
- If you missed class last Thursday, be sure to visit K-State
Online for further information about last Thursday's class.
-
- Read WA, pp.438-45.
-
- Work on "Organizing Your Evaluation Essay" in EW200, pp.57-59.
- Reminder: First draft due 2/7.
|
|
- Review Student Samples (EW200).
-
- Organization of Evaluation Essays.
-
- Evidence in Evaluation Essays: Quoting from your source.
|
Feb
7
|
7 |
- Bring two copies of first draft for Group Peer Review: one
to hand in and one to use in class.
|
|
- Learning about Peer Review and linking review comments to
grading/passing criteria.
- Peer Review Session
- Leave with a revision plan.
|
|
Week 5 |
Feb
12
|
8 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- More on linking review comments to Grading/Passing Criteria.
- Leave with a revision plan.
|
Feb
13
|
-- |
- Evaluation Essay due by 4pm to DE108.
|
|
|
Feb
14
|
9 |
- Read Chapter 4 (75-86) in WA.
- Do exercises on pp.78, p.80.
- Read pp.24-34 in EW200 on revision.
|
|
- Transition to a detailed understanding of arguments.
- Exercise on p.84 in class.
- Review procedures for revision.
|
|
Week 6 |
Feb
19
|
10 |
- Read Chapter 5 (87-108) in WA
- Do exercise on p.90, #1-6, in WA.
- Do exercise on p.97 of WA, choosing 2 of the remaining 9 enthymemic arguments.
|
|
- Structure of Argument: Claims, Stated Reasons, Grounds, Warrants,
Backing, Rebuttals, and Qualifiers.
- Review exercise on pp.90 in WA.
- Review responses to exercise on p.97.
|
-
Proposal Arguments: How to Change Reality
|
Feb
21
|
11 |
- Read Chapter 15 (319-354) in WA.
|
|
- Introduce Proposal Essay assignment.
- Proposals: We should/should no do X.
- Rhetorical situations.
- Practical vs. Policy Proposals.
|
|
Week 7 |
Feb
26
|
12 |
- Bring three possible topics written out to hand in. Have
one that you are fairly sure about and two for back-up.
-
- Read Chapter 7 (129-139) in WA.
- Do exercises on pp.103-4 and pp.138-39.
|
|
- Finding an issue for a proposal.
- Who is your rhetorical audience?
-
- Discuss responses to exercises on pp.103-4 and on pp.138-39 in class. Do exercises on p.107-8 and pp.329-30.
|
Feb
28
|
13 |
- With your topic for your proposal essay in mind, write out answers to questions about "Audience-Based Reasons" on pp.104-5 of WA and write out answers to "Stock Issues" on pp.330-31 of WA.
|
|
- Audience-Based Reasons.
- (Directions for accessing today's
DIWE transcripts.)
|
|
Week 8 |
Mar
5
|
14 |
- Read pp.76-80 in EW200.
- Complete Respond Question
Series for one of the two sample essays. (Follow hyperlink
above to access questions.)
|
|
- How Proposals are presented and organized.
|
Mar
7
|
15 |
- Bring two copies of first draft for Group Peer Review: one
to hand in and one to use in class.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Linking Review comments to grading/passing criteria.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
Mar
8
|
-- |
- Submit essay for Midterm
Portfolio Review to DE108 by 4 p.m.
|
|
|
|
Week 9 |
Mar
12
|
16 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Determine readings for next assignments.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
|
Mar
14
|
17 |
- Both Sections: Read pp.83-84, 88-91, 96-98 in EW200.
-
- Section BF:
- Read in Writing Arguments John Leo's "Kill-for-Kicks
Video Games Desensitizing Our Children" (467-468), Charlie
James's "Littleton Massacre Seems So...American" (475-476),
and Michael Ventura's "Warrior Women: Why Are TV Shows like
Buffy..." (527-530).
-
- Complete a Respond Question
Series (Teen Violence) for one of the essays. (Follow hyperlink
above to access questions.)
-
- Section BQ:
- Read in Writing Arguments Michael Medved's "A
Sickness in the Soul" (488-493), Barbara Streisand's "The
Artist as Citizen" (493-498), and John Leo's "Kill
for Kicks Video Games Desensitizing Our Children" (467-468).
-
- Complete a Respond Question
Series (Pop Culture) for one of the essays. (Follow hyperlink
above to access questions.)
|
|
- Introduce Researched Debate Essay.
- Complete Research Survey on pp. 39-40 of EW200.
- Review model sample essay on pp. 96-8 of EW200.
- Discuss selected essays.
|
Mar
15
|
|
- Proposal due by 4pm to DE 108.
|
|
- --
|
|
Mar
19
|
-- |
-- |
|
NO CLASS |
Mar
21
|
-- |
-- |
|
SPRING BREAK |
|
Week 10 |
Mar
26
|
18 |
- Section BF:
- Read in Writing Arguments Mike Males's "Stop
Blaming Kids and TV" (468-472), Gloria Steinem's "Supremacy
Crimes" (472-475), and Chuck Shelton's "When White
Boys Kill, White Dads Fail" (476-478).
-
- Complete a Respond Question
Series (Teen Violence) for two of the selected essays. (Follow
hyperlink above to access questions.)
-
- Section BQ:
- Read in Writing Arguments Ron Weiskind's "South
Park Movie Revels in Its Really Bad Behavior" (504-505),
Denise Noe's "Parallel Worlds: The Surprising Similarities
(and Differences) of Country-and-Western and Rap" (523-526),
Michael Ventura's "Warrior Women: Why Are TV Shows Like
Buffy..." (527-30), and Mike Males's "Stop Blaming
Kids and TV" (468-472)
-
- Complete a Respond Question
Series (Pop Culture) for two of the selected essays. (Follow
hyperlink above to access questions.)
|
|
- Discuss selected essays.
- Determine several "pro/con" claims for debate topic.
|
Mar
28
|
19 |
- Review all selected essays and "pro/con" claims
generated in class: teen violence
(section BF) or popular
culture (section BQ). Choose one or create one of your own
for your researched debate essay, and then develop three reasons
for the "pro" claim and three reasons for the "con"
claim. Bring a copy of them to class.
-
- Reread pp.83-84, 88-91, 96-98 in EW200.
- Read pp.384-423 in WA and pp.41-42 in EW200.
|
|
- Using sources effectively and avoiding plagiarism.
-
Review student sample essay
and format for essay.
Developing reasons, rebuttals, and complete statements for
each character in your debate.
|
|
Week 11 |
Apr
2
|
20 |
- Bring two copies of first draft for Group Peer Review: one
to hand in and one to use in class.
- Review student sample essay
while drafting.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Review research requirements and how
to cite sources in MLA format.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
|
Apr
4
|
21 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review.
- Check format for citing sources
in MLA format.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Leave with a Revision Plan.
- Introduce Persuasive Research Paper.
|
Persuasive Research Paper
|
Week 12 |
Apr
8
|
-- |
- Researched Debate due by 4pm to DE108.
|
|
- --
|
Apr
9
|
22 |
- Read pp.62-66 in WA.
-
- Read Chap 16 (357-83) and review Chapter 17 (384-405) in WA. Read pp.45-6 in EW200.
-
- Decide topic for persuasive research paper and hand in for
approval.
|
|
- Organizational patterns for research reports; review p.64
in WA.
-
- Finding, Selecting, Using, and Documenting Sources.
-
-
|
Apr
11
|
23 |
- Work on persuasive research paper: Develop working thesis
claim and at least three reasons for your topic, and begin any
additional research.
|
|
- No Class
|
|
Week 13 |
Apr
16
|
24 |
- Bring thesis statement (claim and three reasons) to class.
|
|
- Review sample model persuasive
research essay.
-
- Developing Opposing Views and Refutations.
- To view the transcripts for InterChange conferences, click
the appropriate link below:
- Conference 1 (BF), Conference
2 (BF), Conference 3 (BF),
Conference 4 (BF), and Conference
5 (BF).
- Conference 1 (BQ), Conference
2 (BQ), Conference 3 (BQ),
and Conference 4 (BQ).
|
Apr
18
|
25 |
- Identify the 4-6 sources which will best suit your topic
and thesis claim. Bring them to class.
-
- Bring two copies of your outline to class.
|
|
- More on Selecting, Using, and Documenting Sources.
-
- Do exercises on p.47-50 of EW200.
-
- Review of outlines, paragraph structure, use of sources,
documenting sources.
|
|
Week 14 |
Apr
23
|
26 |
- Bring two copies of first draft for Group Peer Review: one
to hand in and one to use in class.
-
- Refer to the sample model
persuasive research essay and methods for citing
online resources.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Linking Review Comments to grading/passing criteria.
|
Apr
25
|
27 |
- Bring three copies of second draft for Peer Review Session.
-
- Locate hard copies of all sources used and highlight material
used in paper.
-
- Verify correct citation format for "Works Cited"
page and in-test citations, especially for online
resources.
|
|
- Peer Review Session.
- Review of format for "Works Cited" page.
|
Apr
26
|
-- |
Persuasive Research
Paper due by 4pm to DE108. |
|
|
Letter to the Portfolio Reader
|
Week 15 |
Apr
30
|
28 |
- Read pp.3-7 and p.122 in EW200.
- Bring all of your papers to class.
|
|
- Introduction to "Letter to Portfolio Reader"
- Review Student Samples: Common Organizational Patterns and
Details to Support Claims.
|
May
2
|
29 |
- Bring all your papers to class.
|
|
- Planning session for Letter and Gathering Evidence.
-
- Complete outline, including examples, by end of class.
|
|
Week 16 |
May
7
|
30 |
- Revise outline and lists of examples in preparation for in-class
writing.
|
|
- Write "Letter to Portfolio Reader" in class.
|
May
9
|
31 |
- Prepare revisions to existing drafts in preparation for Final
Portfolio Review.
|
|
- Draft workshop, assignment of your choice.
|
|
Finals Week |
- Mon
- May
- 13
|
|
- 10 am-12 noon, Final Portfolios due to DE108.
|
|
Portfolios are now available
for pick-up from the box under my mailbox in Denison 122. |