Intro/Definition/Match/Conclusion format (or some derivation thereof)

 

Points addressed in the same order they are presented in the intro/thesis

 

Each paragraph organized, with ideas logically following each other

 

 

 

Organization

 

Purpose

One specific category/group/term defined (Y) about which reasonable people would disagree

 

One specific borderline example (X) evaluated as a member of that group

 

Stipulative (non-reportive) definition of Y, using logical criteria

 

 

 

Tone/Style

Respectful of the audience and their possible viewpoints

 

Uses language in ways that the average American reader would clearly understand (since there are no rules)

 

Transitions maintain a clear flow of thought throughout

 

Consistent tense and/or person

 

Error-free spelling and punctuation (per page: maximum 2 major errors/5 total errors)

 

MLA format and style

Editing and conventions:

 

Development

 

At least three logical criteria

 

Criteria well defended

 

Summarizes and rebuts at least one reasonable opposition argument

The Definition Essay

Comments on Back

Insufficient

 Acceptable

 Excellent

Student:______________________________________________

This paper will pass final portfolio in its present form:

 

Yes, as it is               Probably, but changes should be made          Probably not without revision

Grade: